Columbia has served Cuban-Spanish food on St. Armands Circle since 1959, and it still does. Many of the restaurants within a short walk of it have changed. The Tommy Bahama you remember is no longer at its old address. The Italian dining room on South Boulevard of the Presidents has a new name and new owners from the same family. A seafood brand from Naples is the next tenant of a storefront that held one business for almost 30 years.
Most of these are not new buildings. The Circle is recovering from Helene and Milton by moving businesses between its existing addresses, and that changes your walk from the parking space to dinner more than any one opening does.
The updated map
Here is what changed at the Circle addresses that moved the most since the 2024 hurricane season.
| Address | Before the 2024 storms | Now or next |
|---|---|---|
| 300 John Ringling Blvd. | Tommy Bahama, for nearly 30 years | Pinchers, Florida seafood, planned for a fall 2026 debut |
| 465 John Ringling Blvd. | Shore | Tommy Bahama |
| 22 S. Boulevard of the Presidents | Le Colonne, founded 1998 | Nonno Umberto, opened December 2025 |
| 28 S. Boulevard of the Presidents | Storm-damaged retail building | Le Shop, Acadia Jewels Fine Jewelry & Design, Chocolate Emporium |
| 24 and 28 N. Boulevard of the Presidents | Gutted two-story shell | Proposed new home for Shore |
Several of these changes started with one closing.
The swap on John Ringling Boulevard
Shore comes first. The restaurant closed its location at 465 John Ringling Blvd. after the 2024 hurricanes. As Your Observer reported in October, restaurateur Tom Leonard still owns that building and leases it to Tommy Bahama. According to WWSB's June report, the move let Tommy Bahama put its retail and restaurant spaces side by side. It also expanded its product line to housewares and home furnishings at its retail space at 371 St. Armands Circle. Tommy Bahama and Kilwin's Chocolate and Ice Cream Shop both held grand reopenings in September 2025.
That move left 300 John Ringling Blvd. empty, and Pinchers is the next tenant. Your Observer's Nov. 1 story described the restaurant as planning a fall debut there. The Southwest Florida seafood brand belongs to Naples-based Phelan Family Brands, and the St. Armands location will be its 11th on the Gulf Coast. Locals who drive inland may already know the one on Lakewood Ranch Main Street. The Circle location is planned as a 200-seat restaurant, and a company spokesperson told Your Observer in late summer that the target was an October opening. The Business Observer reported the same October goal in June. The menu focuses on Florida seafood, with fresh fish, blue crabs and a cheesy crab dip that the article lists among its popular dishes.
St. Armands Circle Association Executive Director Rachel Burns told Your Observer that visitors often ask for Florida seafood. "They want to experience the Florida that they're seeing on TV," she said, describing "that relaxed, upscale vibe where you're dressed up, but you're still wearing your flip-flops."
South Boulevard of the Presidents: same rooms, new kitchens
The same pattern continues on South Boulevard of the Presidents, across the street from Pinchers. At 22 S. Boulevard of the Presidents, Le Colonne served Italian food for more than 25 years after it was founded in 1998. After the 2024 hurricanes, owner Umberto Salustri closed it. His son, Simone Salustri, and Simone's wife, Amber Mayner, began renovating in September 2025 and opened Nonno Umberto in late December 2025. Nonno is Italian for grandfather.
The 300-seat room now has a coastal design. Mayner told Your Observer that the most popular dishes are a whole bronzino deboned by the chef, dry-aged meat and shrimp cocktail. Bread and desserts are made in-house, and shrimp carpaccio was a recent addition to the menu. Her own favorite is the filet mignon with creamy peppercorn sauce and truffle mashed potatoes. The off-season was busy too. "Our summer was absolutely amazing," Mayner said in a mid-September interview.
A few doors down at 40 S. Boulevard of the Presidents, Flambo soft-opened in October 2025 and held its grand opening that November. It celebrates its first anniversary this month. Co-owners Anthony Logan and his son, Kevin Ramlochan, serve Trinidadian food in a 175-seat restaurant. Logan described the cuisine to Your Observer as "the world in one plate." Trinidad's food draws on Spanish, French, African, British, Chinese and Indian cooking. The three dishes guests order most are:
- Butter chicken in a mildly spiced tomato cream sauce
- Flambo red snapper, crispy and served with pickled vegetables
- Trini drunken rice noodles with soy, garlic and sweet pepper
The name comes from Logan's childhood in Trinidad. A flambo is a homemade lantern, and his parents made one from a rum bottle, a T-shirt and kerosene when the power went out.
Farther down the block, the three-unit building at 28 S. Boulevard of the Presidents took severe damage from Helene and Milton, and its owner fully renovated it over the next two years. Le Shop opened there in November 2025 and Acadia Jewels Fine Jewelry & Design followed in January 2026. Chocolate Emporium, the last tenant to sign a lease, soft-opened the week of June 30, 2026. The original Chocolate Emporium is on Anna Maria Island, and owners Kevin and Ruth Schreiner make their chocolate and caramel in-house. As Your Observer reported, that means customers can ask for custom combinations, such as peanut butter cups made with dark chocolate. The Herald-Tribune also covered the opening.
Other storefronts changed hands too. Cariloha Bamboo's space is now Footgear, which moved because its previous location is being renovated and expanded. The Sarasota Style opened at 410 St. Armands Circle in January 2026 and held Chamber ribbon cuttings on Jan. 14 and Jan. 16, according to Your Observer.
The corner that's still waiting
Shore's own return is still in planning. Its owners are planning a new building at 24 and 28 N. Boulevard of the Presidents, at the corner of Madison Drive. Demolition inside the building was underway in May. The plan calls for a boutique shop and casual cafe on the first floor, the restaurant on the second floor, and a residential floor on the third. Leonard has said he would like to use the top floor for a hotel if the zoning ever allows it.
As of Your Observer's Oct. 21 report, the project was still working through two questions in the city code. The first concerns flood protection. The owners plan to spend more than $200,000 to dry-floodproof the ground floor, which means sealing it with glass rated to hold back high water. In the Circle's Commercial Tourism zone, though, dry-floodproofed buildings are limited to 35 feet in height. Residential buildings that are wet-floodproofed, meaning built so water can flow beneath them, can go to 45 feet. The second question is whether a second-floor dining balcony can hang over the sidewalk. The code treats a balcony like an awning, and neither may extend past the property line.
Why the shuffle matters this season
The amount of moving makes sense once you know how many storefronts the Circle has. In June 2026, the St. Armands Circle Association counted 124 potential first-floor tenant spaces. Fewer than 20 were vacant, and many of those were already leased and under renovation. A typical year sees about 10 vacancies. That means the remaining vacancies were close to double the usual number in June, and the openings since then have been filling them.
Upgrades for the whole island are also planned. In December 2025, Sarasota County commissioners awarded $13.5 million in federal disaster-recovery funds to the City of Sarasota's St. Armands Resiliency & Flood Mitigation Project. It was the third-largest of nine awards made from about $57 million. The plan includes flood barriers for business doors, underground water storage, permeable pavement, tide check valves and pump stations, and it is expected to take about five years.
The Circle calendar through mid-December
The St. Armands Circle Association lists these dates on its events page:
- St Armands Circle Art Festival & Sidewalk Sale, Saturday and Sunday, Nov. 14 and 15, 10 a.m. to 5 p.m. It fills St. Armands Circle Park and South Boulevard of the Presidents and is sponsored by ArtFestival.com.
- 48th Annual Holiday Night of Lights, Friday, Dec. 4, 5:30 to 8 p.m., sponsored by the St. Armands Circle Association. The City of Sarasota's listing describes the event's usual format: a carol sing-along, a Santa parade, the lighting of a 60-foot Christmas tree, photos with Mr. and Mrs. Claus, and shopping discounts.
- 22nd Annual Porsches in the Park, Saturday, Dec. 12, 9 a.m. to 2 p.m., in St. Armands Circle Park, sponsored by Suncoast Motorsports.
On festival weekend, South Boulevard of the Presidents will be part of the event grounds. That is the same block as Nonno Umberto, Flambo and the row at 28 S. Boulevard of the Presidents.
If you're thinking about a condo or home near the Circle and want to know how these changes affect a particular street, I'm happy to talk it through with you. I've followed St. Armands closely since moving to Sarasota in 1994, and you can reach me through Anne Diaz-Verson. Let's Connect.